Insurance Companies

As an independent insurance agent, we represent a number of different companies, and act as an advocate on your behalf to help choose the best one for your particular situation. Each company has slightly different underwriting philosophies, appetites and pricing models. What that means to you is there are some companies that view your situation as risky, and charge more, while others may view your situation as less risky and charge less. We can help point you in the right direction and find a financially-sound company that is just right for your particular situation.

The following is a list of the companies we represent along with their website addresses and phone numbers should you have to contact them directly.

The Progressive Group of Insurance Companies has always lived up to its name by being one step ahead of the insurance industry, and finding new and affordable insurance solutions. We began in 1937 with the first drive-in claims office, became the first to introduce reduced rates for low-risk drivers, and then changed the insurance shopping experience by offering comparison rates on the Web.

Progressive continues to find better ways to serve you with our new and personalized Snapshot® program and our Name Your Price® car insurance shopping option.

Phone: (855) 758-0945

Wisconsin Mutual prides itself in service and provides the public with competitively priced, comprehensive products. In addition to being one of the top ranked companies for personal auto, homeowner and farmowner coverages, the company also writes a variety of other items. 

Wisconsin Mutual provides:

  • Automobile
  • Homeowners
  • Dwelling
  • Farmowners
  • Commercial
  • Umbrella

Phone: (608) 836-4663

It's all about passion. We have grown to be the global leader for collector car and boat insurance, but we're still just a family business built on a love for the hobby. Our passion drives us to keep improving our product and to give our clients the best service imaginable.

Phone: 877-922-9701

The Kemper family of companies is one of the nation’s leading insurers. With $8 billion in assets, Kemper is improving the world of insurance by offering personalized solutions for individuals, families and businesses.

Phone: 866.860.9348

As a specialty insurance company, we serve our markets by providing insurance choices that may not be offered by other companies. So, if you're wondering whether or not we can insure a particular product, check us out. Our extensive insurance options may surprise you!

Phone: 800-527-3907

Middleton Fire and Lightning Insurance Company was formed in Wisconsin on January 4, 1876 by a group of individuals, with the idea of providing fire and lightning coverage for eight local communities. After several mergers, including a name change to Middleton Insurance Company we now provide insurance in Columbia, Dane, Dodge, Grant, Green, Iowa, Jefferson, Lafayette, Rock and Sauk counties. We belong to such organizations as Wisconsin Association of Mutual Insurance Companies (WAMIC), National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies (NAMIC), and Cooperative Network (which represents the recent merger of Wisconsin and Minnesota Federation of Cooperatives). Middleton Insurance Company is protected by a comprehensive reinsurance program, as explained below, to handle catastrophic claims. We are also protected by The Policyholders Mutual Insurance Company, which is a solvency fund for town mutuals in Wisconsin.

Phone: 608-831-5642

Integrity is dedicated to making insurance straightforward and honest.

Today, we offer affordable and customizable auto, home, business and life insurance products. Together with Grange Insurance, our affiliate company located in Columbus, OH, we serve customers across 13 states and are committed to selling exclusively through independent agents.

Phone: (800) 348-1741

In business since 1925, we protect individuals, families, and businesses with innovative insurance products backed by world-class customer service. Acuity provides property and casualty insurance products for consumers and businesses in the United States. At Acuity, protecting what matters most to you and your family is our number one goal.

Phone: (800) 242-7666

Pekin Insurance helps our customers build their dreams. Or rebuild their lives. We provide peace of mind and long-term security for our policyholders, shareholders, agents, and employees.

Through wars, peace, and economic downturns and upswings, Pekin Insurance has remained undaunted. We’re flexible, innovative, and we’ve always managed to find ways to get the job done – since 1921.
Today, Pekin Insurance is one of the nation’s most successful insurance providers, with combined assets of $2 billion, more than 800 employees, 1,500 agencies, and 8,500 independent agents.

Phone: 800-322-0160

Risk Placement Services (RPS) is a Managing General Agent/Underwriting Manager and nationally focused wholesale insurance broker. We have ranked in the top five in every insurance industry category and have been consistently ranked as the largest MGA in the country for several years. Headquartered in Itasca, Illinois, our organization has more than 70 branch office and satellite locations. We are comprised of four divisions, National Brokerage, MGA/Binding, Programs and Standard Lines; we also focus on the Environmental, Healthcare, Transportation and Executive Lines segments of the insurance marketplace. For each of our programs and products, we work only with top-rated admitted and non-admitted carriers.

Phone: (866) 595-8413